AMM 375: AI Showdown: ChatGPT vs. Google Bard in Aesthetic Surgery
March 14, 2025
This episode explores the evolving role of AI in providing medical information, particularly within the realm of aesthetic plastic surgery, as of March 3, 2025. It contrasts the capabilities of ChatGPT and Google Bard in delivering accurate and accessible insights on procedures like blepharoplasty and botulinum toxin injections. While ChatGPT excels in some areas, Google Bard provides better information on dermal fillers. However, neither can cite sources, which raises concerns about their reliability in making informed medical decisions. The episode emphasizes the importance of consulting certified professionals despite the convenience offered by AI tools.
Quick Takes
- ChatGPT offers more accurate and accessible information in aesthetic plastic surgery like blepharoplasty and botulinum toxin injections compared to Google Bard.
- Google Bard takes the lead in providing information on dermal filler injections.
- Neither chatbot can cite sources, raising concerns about credibility, especially given the complexity and risks involved in aesthetic plastic surgery.
Episode Transcript
In today’s episode, we’re diving into the intriguing world of AI-driven medical information, just as it evolves in 2025-03-03. A recent study compared the responses of ChatGPT and Google Bard, focusing on aesthetic plastic surgery—covering procedures like blepharoplasty and botulinum toxin injections. The verdict? ChatGPT seems to offer more accurate and accessible information in these areas than Google Bard. However, when it comes to dermal filler injections, Bard takes the lead.
This development might be a game-changer for patients seeking easy access to information. But there’s a catch: neither chatbot can cite their sources. This raises red flags about credibility, especially since aesthetic plastic surgery involves intricate decisions with significant risks. Both ChatGPT and Bard advise consulting certified professionals, yet the absence of verified sources remains a concern.
Doctors, with years of education and clinical experience, build a knowledge base that goes beyond textbooks. While LLM developers aren’t plastic surgeons, the importance of trusting seasoned professionals can’t be overstated when considering medical advice.
Keep these insights in mind during your own explorations into aesthetic treatments. Looking forward to sharing more valuable updates with you next time!